Folio · SPXSet Report · Digest
v0.7.0 STABLE · 2026-11-11 · r4

2026-W43 · Oct 19–Oct 25 · General · Digest · published

Index >>> General >>> Digest

Is Your Losing Trade Coming Back? Here's What the Data Says — Julia Spina Study Digest

Is Your Losing Trade Coming Back? Here's What the Data Says
Julia Spina (@FinancePhoton) · tasty research X Article · Jul 14, 2026
DIGEST
45 DTE · 0.5× LOSS HIT
43%
of strangles
45 DTE · 0.5× RECOVERY
72%
small drawdowns revert
2× LOSS RECOVERY
<50%
all durations
10 DTE · 1× RECOVERY
41.0%
vs 52.7% at 45 DTE

THE STUDY

  • 2025-01-01 → present, 16Δ SPY strangles, durations 45 / 30 / 20 / 10 DTE, opened daily to maximize occurrences.
  • Isolated trades hitting losses of 0.5× / 1× / 2× / 3× initial credit; monitored whether P/L flipped positive before expiration.
  • IV and early management excluded by design — isolates recovery odds, not realistic day-to-day management.

45 DTE: RECOVERY ODDS BY LOSS — % of positions that recovered

45 DTE SPY STRANGLE: RECOVERY ODDS BY LOSS SPY · 2025 to present 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 72% 53% 47% 47% 0.5× 1× 2× 3× 50% line recovery odds fall below 50% right around the 2× loss threshold
45 DTE metric0.5×1×2×3×
Prob. of loss being hit43%27%20%15%
Avg DTE when hit25.821.718.917.4
Prob. of recovery before exp.72%53%47%47%

RECOVERY ODDS: ALL DURATIONS — heatmap, % recovered

STRANGLE RECOVERY ODDS (% RECOVERED) SPY · 2025 to present · rows: duration · cols: loss threshold 0.5×1×2×3× 10 DTE20 DTE30 DTE45 DTE 59.941.020.410.8 68.249.526.024.2 72.655.234.938.3 72.552.747.147.2 recovery odds fall off much faster for shorter-dated strangles
Every duration had a reasonable chance of recovering from a 0.5× loss — but beyond that, shorter-dated options dropped much more rapidly.

AVG DTE WHEN LOSS IS HIT — heatmap, days to expiration remaining

AVG DTE WHEN LOSS IS HIT SPY strangles · 2025 to present · a 1× loss hits near the halfway point of any duration 0.5×1×2×3× 10 DTE20 DTE30 DTE45 DTE 5.44.73.12.2 11.48.57.06.8 17.113.710.29.8 25.821.718.917.4 45 DTE leaves ~3 weeks after a 1× loss; 10 DTE leaves under 5 days
The main reason a blanket 2× stop loss doesn't translate to shorter durations: far less time left to recover once the threshold is hit.

TAKEAWAYS FOR PREMIUM SELLERS

Recovery odds fall quickly as losses worsen — every duration recovered from 0.5× favorably, but by 2×, recovery odds were below 50% across all durations.

Shorter-dated options are much less likely to recover from moderate (1×–2×) losses — consider stop-loss thresholds lower than 2× on shorter-dated positions.

Recovery odds worsen as expiration approaches — early management for undefined-risk trades is critical for risk mitigation.

Don't forget opportunity cost — every day holding a loser is capital that could be redeployed into a more attractive position.

Caveat: SPY avoids single-name binary event risk — earnings and guidance can push a single name through these thresholds in one session; don't treat these percentages as direct benchmarks into a catalyst.

Source: tasty research X Article by Julia Spina (@FinancePhoton), Jul 14 2026. All figures transcribed verbatim; charts rebuilt from the article's stated values. Original: https://x.com/FinancePhoton/status/2076768894510141587
Previous · How MU, INTC, and AMD Are Driving SMH's Volatility — Julia Spina Study DigestNext · Strike Breach vs IV Pop: Does the Source of a Loss Matter? — Julia Spina Study Digest

Entered 2026-10-04 03:23 · updated 2026-10-23 04:27 · rev 3