Folio · SPXSet Report · Digest
v0.7.0 STABLE · 2026-11-11 · r4

2026-W45 · Nov 2–Nov 8 · General · Digest · published

Index >>> General >>> Digest

Using Probability of Profit Effectively — Julia Spina Study Digest

Using Probability of Profit Effectively

Julia Spina Study Digest
Nov 7, 2026 · SPY options · tasty research
STUDY UNIVERSE
SPY options
2016–present · unmanaged, held to expiry
THEORY VS REALITY
68% vs 79%
16Δ strangle POP, theoretical vs realised
SAME 68% POP
+42% vs −37%
avg P/L, 32Δ put vs 32Δ call

STUDY DESIGN

  • The question: what does probability of profit (POP) actually tell a trader — and what does it not tell?
  • Definition: POP is the theoretical probability that a trade will make at least $0.01 at expiration. It helps judge whether the chance of profit is worth the capital, upside and risks — but it says nothing about profitability during the trade, nor about average profit over time.
  • Universe: short 16Δ SPY strangles and short 32Δ SPY puts and calls, 2016 to present. Durations: 20–40 DTE for strangles, 40 DTE for puts/calls.
  • Method: positions held to expiration with no early management (“Unmanaged” in every figure), so the full trade duration is tested. Theoretical POP by the 1 − Δ method; worked example via a 20,000-path Monte Carlo simulation.
  • Sample: 2,692 trades at 40 DTE, 2,700 at 30 DTE, 2,705 at 20 DTE for the strangle tests. No trade counts are given for the 32Δ put/call tests.

HOW POP IS ESTIMATED — AND ITS LIMITS

  • Delta approximates the probability of expiring in the money; most platforms model the expiration-price distribution (most often lognormal with implied volatility) and measure how much of it falls between the breakevens.
  • The models assume a smooth, continuous price distribution with constant volatility — a poor fit when volatility is concentrated in discrete binary events like earnings, or compressed into very short windows.
  • Worked example: a 20,000-path Monte Carlo of a 44 DTE SPY 16Δ strangle at 18% implied volatility. Short call 802, short put 723; breakevens 809.14 / 715.86; 67% profitable at expiration.
HOW THEORETICAL POP IS CALCULATED — 44 DTE SPY 16Δ STRANGLE 20,000-path Monte Carlo at 18% IV · 67% profitable at expiration 809.14 breakeven short call 802 short put 723 715.86 breakeven PROFITABLE AT EXPIRATION finishes between the breakevens loss above 809.14 loss below 715.86 SPY price ($) · schematic of the labelled levels only — simulated paths not plotted
LevelSPY priceRole
Upper breakeven809.14strike + credit
Short call (16Δ)802short strike
Short put (16Δ)723short strike
Lower breakeven715.86strike − credit
Profitable at expiration67%Monte Carlo result
Labels transcribed exactly as shown in the article figure; the fan of simulated price paths carries no per-path values and is not plotted.

POP IS AN ESTIMATE, NOT A PREDICTION

  • A 16Δ strangle’s theoretical POP is around 68%. Realised POP was 79% at every duration tested — about 10–11 percentage points higher than theory.
  • Offered explanation: SPY prices tend to mean-revert, and options stay within their expected range more often than the model predicts.
  • Read it as a guide, not an exact figure.
THEORETICAL VS. REALIZED POP — SPY 16Δ STRANGLES Unmanaged · 2016–present · ~2,700 trades per duration 0% 25% 50% 75% 100% 68% 79.2% 40 DTE 68% 78.5% 30 DTE 68% 78.8% 20 DTE Theoretical (1 − Δ) Realized POP
DurationTheoretical POP (1 − Δ)Realized POP# of trades
40 DTE68%79.2%2,692
30 DTE68%78.5%2,700
20 DTE68%78.8%2,705
Values transcribed exactly as labeled in the article (tasty research).

POP VS STAYING PROFITABLE

  • POP measures the chance of profiting at expiration, not how profitability evolves during the trade: 79% finished profitable, but only 17–25% were profitable for the entire duration.
  • Shorter durations stayed green throughout more often — less time for the position to move against the trader. Most ultimately-profitable trades were losers at some point.
  • Recovery: 61–66% of strangles recovered from a 25% loss, 53–59% from a 50% loss, and about a coin flip (47–52%) from a 75% loss (20–40 DTE rows; the 10 DTE row runs lower).
DurationTheoretical POPRealized POPAlways profitable
40 DTE68%79.2%16.8%
30 DTE68%78.5%20.0%
20 DTE68%78.8%25.1%
DurationRecovered from down 25%Recovered from down 50%Recovered from down 75%
40 DTE66% (59% of trades hit it)59% (46%)52% (37%)
30 DTE63% (57%)56% (46%)50% (37%)
20 DTE61% (53%)53% (42%)47% (34%)
10 DTE58% (46%)49% (36%)42% (29%)
First cell of each row: % that finished profitable after hitting that loss level. In parentheses: % of all trades that hit the loss level. SPY 16Δ strangles, unmanaged, 2016–present.

SAME POP, DIFFERENT EXPECTED VALUE

  • Same 68% theoretical POP, three very different outcomes at 40 DTE: the 32Δ put won 87.2% and averaged +41.8% of credit; the 32Δ call won 60.7% and averaged −37.0%; the 16Δ strangle won 79.2% and averaged +22.2%.
  • Reason: POP treats every win and loss the same, regardless of size. A short option can only make the credit received, but it can lose many multiples of it.
  • The average winning trade collected almost all the credit; the average losing put lost 3.4× its credit, the losing call 2.3×. So the put needed to win about 78% of the time to break even, the call about 72%.
SAME POP, DIFFERENT EXPECTED VALUE — SPY 40 DTE All three: 68% theoretical POP · unmanaged · 2016–present 32Δ Put 87.2% 32Δ Call 60.7% 16Δ Strangle 79.2% 0% 50% 100% Avg P/L: put +41.8% of credit · call −37.0% · strangle +22.2%
Strategy (40 DTE)Theoretical POPRealized POPAvg P/L ($)Avg P/L (%)
32Δ Put68%87.2%$235+41.8%
32Δ Call68%60.7%-$112−37.0%
16Δ Strangle68%79.2%$112+22.2%
WIN RATE ALONE DOESN’T SET THE EDGE — % OF CREDIT SPY 40 DTE · unmanaged · 2016–present 0% 32Δ Put +98% −341% 32Δ Call +91% −235% Avg win (green, right) vs avg loss (red, left) · breakeven POP: put 77.7% · call 72.0%
Strategy (40 DTE)Avg win (% of credit)Avg loss (% of credit)Breakeven POP
32Δ Put+98%−341%77.7%
32Δ Call+91%−235%72.0%
Breakeven POP = win rate needed for expected value of zero. No strangle row is given in this figure. Values transcribed exactly as labeled (tasty research).

COVER NOTE

  • The article’s cover image (“UNDERSTANDING PROBABILITY OF PROFIT”) shows a fan of simulated SPY price paths from about $770 at entry, over 0–40 days, across a $675–$875 price axis. It carries no strike, breakeven or percentage labels and no legend, so it is described here in words only — no visual is rebuilt from it.

WHAT THIS MEANS FOR TRADERS

POP is an estimate, not a prediction. The 16Δ strangle’s 68% theoretical POP came in at 79% realised at every duration — use the number as a guide, not a guarantee.

Finishing profitable is not the same as staying profitable. Only 17–25% of strangles were green the whole way; most winners were losers at some point, and recovery from a deep drawdown is roughly a coin flip.

Win rate alone does not set the edge. Three trades can share a 68% POP and end at +42%, +22% and −37% — the size of wins versus losses decides whether a strategy pays over time.

Check the breakeven win rate before the trade. A short 32Δ put needs to win ~78% of the time just to break even; a short 32Δ call ~72%.

Source: tasty research X Article by Julia Spina (@FinancePhoton), Nov 7 2026. Figures transcribed verbatim; charts rebuilt from exact labeled values only. Original: x.com/FinancePhoton/article/2118770953182138699
Previous · 15 Years of SPX Data Revealed Three Key Patterns. Here's How They Impact 0 DTEs. — Julia Spina Study DigestNext · Why Your 0DTE Trade Gets Harder to Enter the Later You Wait|學習筆記 2026-10-13

Entered 2026-11-06 20:27 · updated 2026-11-06 20:32 · rev 7