2026-W45 · Nov 2–Nov 8 · General · Digest · published
STUDY DESIGN
HOW POP IS ESTIMATED — AND ITS LIMITS
| Level | SPY price | Role |
|---|---|---|
| Upper breakeven | 809.14 | strike + credit |
| Short call (16Δ) | 802 | short strike |
| Short put (16Δ) | 723 | short strike |
| Lower breakeven | 715.86 | strike − credit |
| Profitable at expiration | 67% | Monte Carlo result |
POP IS AN ESTIMATE, NOT A PREDICTION
| Duration | Theoretical POP (1 − Δ) | Realized POP | # of trades |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40 DTE | 68% | 79.2% | 2,692 |
| 30 DTE | 68% | 78.5% | 2,700 |
| 20 DTE | 68% | 78.8% | 2,705 |
POP VS STAYING PROFITABLE
| Duration | Theoretical POP | Realized POP | Always profitable |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40 DTE | 68% | 79.2% | 16.8% |
| 30 DTE | 68% | 78.5% | 20.0% |
| 20 DTE | 68% | 78.8% | 25.1% |
| Duration | Recovered from down 25% | Recovered from down 50% | Recovered from down 75% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40 DTE | 66% (59% of trades hit it) | 59% (46%) | 52% (37%) |
| 30 DTE | 63% (57%) | 56% (46%) | 50% (37%) |
| 20 DTE | 61% (53%) | 53% (42%) | 47% (34%) |
| 10 DTE | 58% (46%) | 49% (36%) | 42% (29%) |
SAME POP, DIFFERENT EXPECTED VALUE
| Strategy (40 DTE) | Theoretical POP | Realized POP | Avg P/L ($) | Avg P/L (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 32Δ Put | 68% | 87.2% | $235 | +41.8% |
| 32Δ Call | 68% | 60.7% | -$112 | −37.0% |
| 16Δ Strangle | 68% | 79.2% | $112 | +22.2% |
| Strategy (40 DTE) | Avg win (% of credit) | Avg loss (% of credit) | Breakeven POP |
|---|---|---|---|
| 32Δ Put | +98% | −341% | 77.7% |
| 32Δ Call | +91% | −235% | 72.0% |
COVER NOTE
WHAT THIS MEANS FOR TRADERS
POP is an estimate, not a prediction. The 16Δ strangle’s 68% theoretical POP came in at 79% realised at every duration — use the number as a guide, not a guarantee.
Finishing profitable is not the same as staying profitable. Only 17–25% of strangles were green the whole way; most winners were losers at some point, and recovery from a deep drawdown is roughly a coin flip.
Win rate alone does not set the edge. Three trades can share a 68% POP and end at +42%, +22% and −37% — the size of wins versus losses decides whether a strategy pays over time.
Check the breakeven win rate before the trade. A short 32Δ put needs to win ~78% of the time just to break even; a short 32Δ call ~72%.
Entered 2026-11-06 20:27 · updated 2026-11-06 20:32 · rev 7